(no subject)
Apr. 30th, 2004 11:52 amyou know something that i am tired of?
i am tired of people trying to defend a horrible practice with the following argument:
"don't you silly rabbits realize that [horrible practice] has been a part of [history] for as long as people have been in existence? [horrible practice] is therefore a fact of life, and you are naive not to expect, (and by extension, wrong to condemn) [horrible practice,] which is somehow excused by our nature."
Here is a clue for you types. Citing history does not win an argument. It is a logical fallacy called "The Appeal to Tradition" with a little bit of the logical fallacy "Appeal to Nature" thrown in. The Appeal to Tradition says (simplified) that something is true "because it has always been done that way." It is a fallacy simply because the traditional may simply be wrong. Natural Law is subject to the same problem (not, in this case, that "Nature" is wrong, but what is called "Natural Law" could be built upon a flawed assumption. ("All the celestial bodies revolve around the earth, therefore it is the center of the universe."))
So the bottom line... torture of humans, is in no way excused by the fact that humans have always tortured other humans. We may be rushing to judgement, the facts may not all be evident, etc... but we are not right to "do what we want because people always have."
i am tired of people trying to defend a horrible practice with the following argument:
"don't you silly rabbits realize that [horrible practice] has been a part of [history] for as long as people have been in existence? [horrible practice] is therefore a fact of life, and you are naive not to expect, (and by extension, wrong to condemn) [horrible practice,] which is somehow excused by our nature."
Here is a clue for you types. Citing history does not win an argument. It is a logical fallacy called "The Appeal to Tradition" with a little bit of the logical fallacy "Appeal to Nature" thrown in. The Appeal to Tradition says (simplified) that something is true "because it has always been done that way." It is a fallacy simply because the traditional may simply be wrong. Natural Law is subject to the same problem (not, in this case, that "Nature" is wrong, but what is called "Natural Law" could be built upon a flawed assumption. ("All the celestial bodies revolve around the earth, therefore it is the center of the universe."))
So the bottom line... torture of humans, is in no way excused by the fact that humans have always tortured other humans. We may be rushing to judgement, the facts may not all be evident, etc... but we are not right to "do what we want because people always have."